Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Peace Studies

Scholarly, Popular and Trade or Professional Publications

Scholarly or Academic Journals

  • Are written by scholars for scholars.
    • Note, however, that popular media and news sources may be primary sources for research.
    • Purpose and context are crucial.
  • Cite their sources documenting their arguments and data, thereby:
    • facilitating the ongoing scholarly conversation;
    • giving credit to the work of others.
  • Conform to the standards of a scholarly discipline.
  • Refereed or Peer-Reviewed Journals
    • Are a subset of scholarly journals.
    • Are reviewed (refereed) by a panel of scholars (peers) before acceptance to determine if potential articles meet the standards of the discipline and of the journal.
    • Are guaranteed to be scholarly.
    • For example, Journal of Peace Research.
    • Articles in other journals may still be scholarly but lack this "guarantee" -- look for cites and documentation.

Trade or Professional Periodicals

  • Written for practitioners or the well-informed public.
  • May or may not cite sources.
  • Often look like popular periodicals.
  • For example, American Libraries or Scientific American.

Popular Magazines and News Sources

  • Written by journalists and professional writers for the general public.
  • Generally have no documentation beyond an occasional in-text reference.
  • Have many glossy ads and colorful illustrations.
  • For example, Time Magazine, Paris Match or Cat Fancier's Weekly.
  • Exceptions:
    • May contain serious, well-informed analysis, e.g. lengthy editorials in the New York Times
    • May contain invaluable investigative reporting, e.g. the Watergate series in the Washington Post